Question 641
Choose the correct indirect speech form of the following sentence.
Rohan said to Manasi, "I have no rose to give you now."
- AOption (a)
Rohan told Manasi that he has no rose to give her then.
- BOption (b)
Rohan told Manasi that he had no rose to give her then.
- COption (c)
Rohan told Manasi that he had had no rose to give her then.
- DOption (d)
Rohan told Manasi that he had no rose to give her now.
View answer & explanationHide answer & explanation
Correct answer
Rohan told Manasi that he had no rose to give her then.
Why this answer is correct
The correct answer is Option 2.
Key Points
- Indirect Speech: Rohan told Manasi that he had no rose to give her then.
- Key Conversions:
- Pronoun Change:
- "I" becomes "he" (to match the reporting subject "Rohan").
- "you" becomes "her" (to match the object "Manasi").
- Tense Change:
- Direct speech in present perfect ("have no rose") changes to past perfect ("had no rose") in indirect speech.
- Time Expression:
- "now" changes to "then" in indirect speech.
- Reporting Verb:
- The reporting verb "said to" changes to "told" in indirect speech.
- Punctuation and Format:
- Quotation marks are removed in indirect speech.
- The sentence begins with the reporting clause and is followed by the reported speech.
Therefore, the correct answer is Option 2.
Correct Sentence: Rohan told Manasi that he had no rose to give her then.
Additional Information
- Option 1: "Rohan told Manasi that he has no rose to give her then."
- The verb "has" is incorrect as it remains in the present tense instead of changing to the past tense.
- Option 3: "Rohan told Manasi that he had had no rose to give her then."
- The double past perfect "had had" is unnecessary and grammatically incorrect in this context.
- Option 4: "Rohan told Manasi that he had no rose to give her now."
- The word "now" is incorrect as it does not align with the shift to indirect speech (should be "then").