Which type of bill cannot originate in the State Legislative Council of an Indian state?
I. Money Bill
II. Ordinary Bill
- AOption (a)
Only I
- BOption (b)
Only II
- COption (c)
Both I and II
- DOption (d)
Neither I nor II
View answer & explanationHide answer & explanation
Correct answer
Only I
Why this answer is correct
The correct answer is Only I.
Key Points
- Money Bills cannot originate in the State Legislative Council. They can only originate in the State Legislative Assembly, as per Article 198 of the Indian Constitution.
- A Money Bill deals with taxation, public expenditure, borrowing of money by the government, or matters related to the Consolidated Fund of the state.
- The State Legislative Assembly has the exclusive power to discuss and pass a Money Bill. The Legislative Council, where it exists, can only provide recommendations, which the Assembly may accept or reject.
- Ordinary Bills, on the other hand, can originate in either the State Legislative Assembly or the State Legislative Council, where a bicameral system exists.
- Therefore, the statement "Money Bill cannot originate in the State Legislative Council" is correct, while the statement for Ordinary Bills is incorrect. Hence, Only I is correct.
Additional Information
- Money Bill:
- A Money Bill is defined under Article 110 of the Indian Constitution at the Union level and Article 198 at the state level.
- It exclusively deals with financial matters like taxation, public expenditure, and government borrowings.
- The Speaker of the Legislative Assembly has the final authority to decide whether a bill is a Money Bill.
- The role of the State Legislative Council, if present, is advisory; they must return the bill to the Assembly within 14 days, with or without recommendations.
- The Assembly is not bound to accept the recommendations made by the Legislative Council.
- Ordinary Bill:
- Unlike a Money Bill, an Ordinary Bill can originate in either the Legislative Assembly or the Legislative Council in states with a bicameral legislature.
- Both Houses must pass the Ordinary Bill before it is sent to the Governor for assent.
- If there is a disagreement between the two Houses, the decision of the Legislative Assembly prevails.
- Bicameral System in India:
- Only a few Indian states have a bicameral legislature, including Uttar Pradesh, Maharashtra, Bihar, Karnataka, Andhra Pradesh, and Telangana.
- In these states, the legislature comprises two Houses: the Legislative Assembly (Vidhan Sabha) and the Legislative Council (Vidhan Parishad).
- In states with a unicameral system, there is only a Legislative Assembly, and all bills originate and are passed within this single House.
- Important Articles of the Indian Constitution:
- Article 198: Deals with Money Bills in state legislatures.
- Article 199: Defines the scope of what constitutes a Money Bill.
- Article 200: Outlines the Governor's role in assenting to bills passed by the state legislature.
- Article 110: Defines Money Bills at the Union level.
- Article 111: Discusses the President's role in assenting to Money Bills.
Important Points
- The State Legislative Council’s powers are limited when compared to the Legislative Assembly, especially for Money Bills.
- The existence of a Legislative Council in a state is optional. A state can abolish or create a Legislative Council through a resolution passed by the Legislative Assembly and approved by Parliament.
- The decision-making authority for financial matters in a state rests primarily with the Legislative Assembly.
- The bicameral system is aimed at providing a system of checks and balances but is limited in its scope for financial legislation.
- The Governor's assent is mandatory for all bills (Money or Ordinary) passed by the state legislature before they become laws.