The following sentence has been split into four segments. Identify the segment that contains a grammatical error.
The teacher asked the class / to be quiet while she / explained the new assignment, / but nobody is listening.
- AOption (a)
to be quiet while she
- BOption (b)
explained the new assignment
- COption (c)
but nobody is listening
- DOption (d)
The teacher asked the class
View answer & explanationHide answer & explanation
Correct answer
but nobody is listening
Why this answer is correct
The correct answer is Option 3.
Key Points
- The primary error in the sentence is an inconsistency in tense.
- The sentence begins in the Simple Past Tense with the verb asked and the subsequent clause explained.
- To maintain grammatical parallelism and logical flow, the final clause must also be in the past tense. The phrase is listening (Present Continuous) should be changed to was listening (Past Continuous).
- Thus, the error is located in the segment but nobody is listening.
Therefore, the correct answer is 3.
Correct Sentence: 'The teacher asked the class to be quiet while she explained the new assignment, but nobody was listening.'
Additional Information
- The teacher asked the class: This is the main clause in the Past Indefinite tense and is grammatically correct.
- to be quiet while she: This uses an infinitive phrase (to be) and a subordinating conjunction (while) correctly.
- explained the new assignment: This maintains the Past Tense consistency established by the word 'asked'.
- In English grammar, when describing a sequence of events or a state of being in the past, all related verbs should generally reflect the past timeframe.