Read the given statements and conclusions carefully. Assuming that the information given in the statements is true, even if it appears to be at variance with commonly known facts, decide which of the given conclusions logically follow(s) from the statements.
Statement I: Some fish are frogs.
Statement II: Some frogs are whales.
Conclusion I: Some fish are whales.
Conclusion II: No fish is a whale.
- AOption (a)
Only I follows
- BOption (b)
Only II follows
- COption (c)
Either I or II follows
- DOption (d)
Neither I nor II follows
View answer & explanationHide answer & explanation
Correct answer
Either I or II follows
Why this answer is correct
Statements:
Statement I: Some fish are frogs.
Statement II: Some frogs are whales.
The least possible Venn diagram for the given statement is:
Conclusion:
I. Some fish are whales - False (No definite relation given between fish and frogs, so it can be possible only).
II. No fish is a whale - False (No definite relation given between fish and frogs, so it can be possible only).
Here, Conclusion I and II forms complementary pair for either-or.
So, Either conclusion I or II follow.
Hence, the correct answer is "Option 3".
Additional Information
Conditions of Either-or case:
- The elements should be the same in both the statements.
- Both the conclusions should be false individually.
- One conclusion should be positive and one conclusion should be negative (Complementary pair) -
The two complementary pairs are:
-
All + Some not
-
No + Some
Note: Some + Some not is not considered under Either -or case.



























