One pipe can fill a tank in 4 minutes while another pipe can empty the completely filled tank in 8 minutes. If both the pipes are opened together when the tank is empty, then how many minutes will it take to fill one-half of the tank?
- AOption (a)
8 minutes
- BOption (b)
5 minutes
- COption (c)
9 minutes
- DOption (d)
4 minutes
View answer & explanationHide answer & explanation
Correct answer
4 minutes
Why this answer is correct
Shortcut Trick
Combined efficiency of filling pipe (A) and emptying pipe (B) = (1/4 − 1/8) = 1/8 per minute.
Time to fill full tank = 8 minutes.
Time to fill one-half tank = 8 × (1/2) = 4 minutes.
∴ The correct answer is 4 min.
Alternate Method
Given: Filling time = 4 min, Emptying time = 8 min.
Formula Used: Total Work = LCM of time; Efficiency = Work ÷ Time.
| Pipe | Time (min) | Total Capacity | Efficiency |
|---|---|---|---|
| Filling Pipe (A) | 4 | 8 units | +2 |
| Emptying Pipe (B) | 8 | −1 |
⇒ Net efficiency of (A + B) = 2 − 1 = 1 unit/min.
⇒ Total capacity to be filled = 1/2 × 8 units = 4 units.
⇒ Time required = 4 units ÷ 1 unit/min = 4 minutes.
∴ The correct answer is 4 min.
Additional Information
Pipes and Cisterns Logic
Filling pipes have positive efficiency while emptying pipes (leakages) have negative efficiency.
Time-Work Relationship
If two pipes A and B fill/empty a tank in 'x' and 'y' hours respectively, then the net part filled/emptied in 1 hour = (1/x ± 1/y).