Question 1701
Read the given statements and conclusions carefully. Assuming that the information given in the statements is true, even if it appears to be at variance with commonly known facts, decide which of the given conclusion(s) logically follow(s) from the statements.
Statements:
Some Indians are Americans.
Some Americans are Chinese.
Conclusions (I): No Chinese is an American.
Conclusions (II): All Indians are Chinese.
- AOption (a)
Only conclusion (I) follows.
- BOption (b)
Neither conclusion (I) nor (II) follows.
- COption (c)
Only conclusion (II) follows.
- DOption (d)
Both conclusions (I) and (II) follow
View answer & explanationHide answer & explanation
Correct answer
Neither conclusion (I) nor (II) follows.
Why this answer is correct
Given
Statements:
Some Indians are Americans.
Some Americans are Chinese.
The least possible Venn diagram for the given statement is:
Conclusions:
I. No Chinese is an American.
The statement "Some Americans are Chinese" explicitly establishes an overlap between Americans and Chinese.
This conclusion, which denies any overlap, is a direct contradiction of Statement 2.
II. All Indians are Chinese.
The statements only establish partial links (Some I are A; Some A are C).
This does not guarantee any relationship between Indians and Chinese, much less a universal one ("All").
The relationship is uncertain.
So, Neither conclusion (I) nor (II) follows.
Hence, the correct answer is "Option 2".