Let P be the sum of first n positive terms of an increasing arithmetic progression A. Let Q be the sum of first n positive terms of another increasing arithmetic progression B.
Let P ∶ Q = (5n + 4) ∶ (9n + 6)
If d is the common difference of A, and D is the common difference of B, then which one of the following is always correct ?
- AOption (a)
D > d
- BOption (b)
D < d
- COption (c)
7D > 12d
- DOption (d)
None of the above
View answer & explanationHide answer & explanation
Correct answer
D > d
Why this answer is correct
Solution:
There are two AP with the different first terms and common difference.
For the first AP A:
Let the first term be a and common difference = d
Sum of n terms P = \(\frac{n}{2}[2a+(n-1)d]\)
and nth term an = a + (n - 1)d
For the second AP B:
Let the first term be M and common difference = D
Sum of n terms Q = \(\frac{n}{2}[2M+(n-1)D]\)
and nth term Mn = M + (n - 1)D
It is given that
\(\frac{Sum\ of\ n\ terms\ of\ first\ A.P}{Sum\ of\ n\ terms\ of\ second\ A.P }= \frac{5n+4}{9n+6}\)
⇒ \(\frac{\frac{n}{2}[2a+(n-1)d]}{\frac{n}{2}[2M+(n-1)D] }= \frac{5n+4}{9n+6}\)
⇒ \(\frac{[2a+(n-1)d]}{[2M+(n-1)D] }= \frac{5n+4}{9n+6} \)
⇒ \(\frac{a+\left ( \frac{n-1}{2} \right )d}{M+\left ( \frac{n-1}{2} \right )D}= \frac{5n+4}{9n+6} \).....(1)
Now, we need to find the ratio of the first term of A and B
\(\frac{1^{st}\ term\ of\ A}{1^{st}\ term\ of\ B}\)
= \(\frac{a}{M}\)
Hence, \(\frac{n-1}{2}=0\Rightarrow n=1\)
Putting n = 1 in equation (1), we get
\(\frac{a}{M}=\frac{5(1)+4}{9(1)+6}\)
⇒ \(\frac{a}{M}=\frac{9}{15}\)
⇒ \(\frac{a}{M}=\frac{3}{5}\)
⇒ \(\frac{1^{st}\ term\ of\ A}{1^{st}\ term\ of\ B} =\frac{3}{5}\)
Now, we need to find the ratio of the second term of A and B
\(\frac{2^{nd}\ term\ of\ A}{2^{nd}\ term\ of\ B}\)
= \(\frac{a+(2-1)d}{M+(2-1)D}\)
= \(\frac{a+d}{M+D}\)
Hence, \(\frac{n-1}{2}=1\Rightarrow n=3\)
Putting n = 3 in equation (1), we get
\(\frac{a+d}{M+D}=\frac{5(3)+4}{9(3)+6}\)
⇒ \(\frac{a+d}{M+D}=\frac{19}{33}\)
⇒ \(\frac{2^{nd}\ term\ of\ A}{2^{nd}\ term\ of\ B} =\frac{19}{33}\)
Let the first term of A = 3 and the second term of A = 19
then common difference d = 19 - 3 = 16
Let the first term of B = 5 and the second term of B = 33
then common difference D = 33 - 5 = 28
Hence, D > d
∴ The correct option is (1)