Which oligopoly model (s) have the same results as the competitive model?
- AOption (a)
Cournot
- BOption (b)
Bertrand
- COption (c)
Stackelberg
- DOption (d)
Both Cournot and Stackelberg
View answer & explanationHide answer & explanation
Correct answer
Bertrand
Why this answer is correct
The correct answer is - Bertrand
Key Points
- Bertrand Model
- The Bertrand model of oligopoly assumes that firms compete by setting prices rather than quantities.
- In this model, if firms produce homogeneous goods, price competition drives the price down to marginal cost, resulting in the same outcome as perfect competition.
- This happens because any price above marginal cost incentivizes firms to undercut each other to capture the entire market, leading to a price war.
- The end result is that firms earn zero economic profit, just like in a perfectly competitive market.
Additional Information
- Cournot Model
- The Cournot model assumes that firms compete on quantity rather than price.
- Firms decide their output simultaneously and assume that the competitor’s output remains constant.
- The Cournot equilibrium does not lead to the same results as perfect competition because firms restrict output to keep prices above marginal cost, leading to positive economic profits.
- Stackelberg Model
- The Stackelberg model introduces a leader-follower dynamic in competition.
- The leader firm decides its output first, and the follower firm reacts to the leader’s decision.
- While the Stackelberg model results in higher output and lower prices compared to Cournot, it still does not achieve the competitive outcome where price equals marginal cost.
- Combination of Cournot and Stackelberg
- Combining both models does not yield a competitive outcome because both models inherently involve strategic behavior by firms to restrict output or manipulate pricing to maintain profits.
- The resulting equilibrium is less competitive than the Bertrand model's marginal-cost pricing.