Arrange the introduction/coinage of the following concepts in chronological order (oldest to latest):
A. Primitive Socialist Accumulation
B. Development by Dispossession
C. Accumulation by Dispossession
D. Primitive Capitalist Accumulation
E. Knife edge Instability
Choose the correct answer from the options given below:
- AOption (a)
D, A, E, B, C
- BOption (b)
A, D, B, E, C
- COption (c)
D, A, E, C, B
- DOption (d)
A, D, B, C, E
View answer & explanationHide answer & explanation
Correct answer
D, A, E, C, B
Why this answer is correct
The correct answer is – D, A, E, C, B
Key Points
- Primitive Capitalist Accumulation
- Introduced by Karl Marx in the 19th century, particularly discussed in Capital, Volume I.
- Refers to the historical process through which producers were separated from the means of production.
- Includes enclosures, colonial plunder, and forced commodification of labor.
- Forms the foundation of the capitalist mode of production.
- Primitive Socialist Accumulation
- Developed by Evgeny Preobrazhensky in the early 20th century.
- Explains capital formation in a socialist economy through surplus extraction from agriculture.
- Associated with early Soviet economic debates.
- Represents a socialist adaptation of the idea of primitive accumulation.
- Knife-edge Instability
- Part of the Harrod–Domar growth model formulated in the mid-20th century.
- Suggests that economic growth is unstable unless actual growth equals warranted growth.
- Small deviations can lead to cumulative expansion or contraction.
- Highlights inherent instability in capitalist growth processes.
- Accumulation by Dispossession
- Coined by David Harvey in the early 2000s.
- Extends Marx’s idea of primitive accumulation to modern capitalism.
- Includes privatization, financialization, and commodification of public assets.
- Explains ongoing capital accumulation under neoliberalism.
- Development by Dispossession
- Emerged later in development economics and political economy literature.
- Used to explain land acquisition, displacement, and resource extraction in developing countries.
- Closely linked to state-led development and globalization.
- Frequently applied in studies of agrarian change and urbanization.
Additional Information
- Chronological arrangement in economics
- Such questions test understanding of the evolution of economic thought.
- Older concepts are usually rooted in classical or Marxian political economy.
- Later concepts often reinterpret earlier theories in modern institutional and global contexts.