Explanation:
Method 1: Moment Distribution method
Assume ‘R’ sinks by Δ
Fixed End Moments are given by
\({M_{{F_{QR}}}} = \frac{{ - 6EI \times {\rm{\Delta ;}}}}{{{L^2}}};\)
\({M_{{F_{RQ}}}} = \frac{{ - 6EI \times {\rm{\Delta ;}}}}{{{L^2}}}\)
\({M_{{F_{RS}}}} = ;{M_{{F_{SR}}}} = 0\)
Distribution Factor at R is 0.5 & 0.5 for each end respectively due to symmetricity
By Analysis of beam QR,
\(\sum {M_Q} = 0\)
\(\frac{{4.5 \times EI \times {\rm{\Delta ;}}}}{{{L^2}}} + \frac{{3 \times EI \times {\rm{\Delta ;}}}}{{{L^2}}} = P \times L\)
\({\rm{\Delta ;}} = \frac{{{\rm{P}} \times {{\rm{L}}^3}}}{{7.5{\rm{;EI}}}}{\rm{;}}\)
Method 2: Slope deflection method
\({M_{QR}} = \frac{{2EI}}{l}\left( {{\theta _R} - \frac{{3{\rm{\Delta }}}}{l}} \right)\)
\({M_{RQ}} = \frac{{2EI}}{l}\left( {2{\theta _R} - \frac{{3{\rm{\Delta }}}}{l}} \right)\)
\({M_{RS}} = \frac{{2EI}}{l}\left( {2{\theta _R}} \right)\)
If reaction at S is equal to zero
MRQ + MQR + P × l = 0
\(\frac{{6EI{\theta _R}}}{l} - \frac{{12EI{\rm{\Delta }}}}{{{l^2}}} + Pl = 0\)
\(\frac{{6EI{\theta _R}}}{l} - \frac{{12EI}}{{{l^2}}} \times \frac{{P{l^3}}}{{\beta EI}} + Pl = 0\)
\(\frac{{6EI{\theta _R}}}{l} - \frac{{12Pl}}{\beta } + PL = 0\) -----(i)
From equilibrium of joint
MRQ + MRS = 0
\(\frac{{8EI{Q_R}}}{l} - \frac{{6EI{\rm{\Delta }}}}{{{l^2}}} = 0\)
\(\frac{{6EI{\theta _R}}}{l} = \frac{6}{8}\left( {\frac{{6EI}}{{{l^2}}} \times \frac{{P{l^3}}}{{\beta EI}}} \right)\)
\(\frac{{6EI{\theta _R}}}{l} = \frac{{36;Pl}}{{8\beta }}\) ----(ii)
⇒ From (i) & (ii)
\(\frac{{36Pl}}{{8\beta }} - \frac{{96Pl}}{{8\beta }}Pl = 0\)
\(\Rightarrow \frac{{60Pl}}{{8\beta }} + Pl = 0\)
\(\Rightarrow 8\beta = 60\)
\(\beta = \frac{{60}}{8} = 7.5\)