Consider the following statements about Marxist view of State -
(I) Realists argue that the Marxist view of State is reductionist.
(II) It reduces the State to a simple tool in the hands of ruling class, with no will of its own.
Choose the correct option -
- AOption (a)
Only (I) is correct
- BOption (b)
Only (II) is correct
- COption (c)
(I) and (II) both are incorrect
- DOption (d)
(I) and (II) both are correct
View answer & explanationHide answer & explanation
Correct answer
(I) and (II) both are correct
Why this answer is correct
The correct answer is 'Option 4: (I) and (II) both are correct'
Key Points
- Marxist view of State:
- The Marxist view of the state primarily focuses on the idea that the state is an instrument of oppression used by the ruling class to maintain its dominance over the working class.
- According to this perspective, the state serves the interests of the ruling class (bourgeoisie) and is used to perpetuate their control over the means of production.
- Reductionist Argument:
- Realists argue that the Marxist view of the state is reductionist because it simplifies the complex nature of the state by reducing it to merely a tool in the hands of the ruling class.
- This view overlooks the various functions and roles that the state plays beyond merely serving the ruling class, such as maintaining law and order, providing public services, and representing the collective interests of society.
- Instrument of the Ruling Class:
- The Marxist perspective posits that the state has no will of its own and acts as a direct instrument of the ruling class.
- This means that the state's policies and actions are primarily driven by the interests of the ruling class, rather than being autonomous or independent.