Which of the following observations are correct about deliberative democracy?
A. Deliberative democracy describes a normative ideal in which free and equal citizens publicly exchange reasons with one another.
B. They do with a view to reaching a consensus about some issue or policy or about the principles underlying the system as a whole.
C. The central claim is that a political decision or system is legitimate even if it cannot command free and reasoned agreement among equals
D. Clearly this is a practical conception, which contemporary political life- with partisan rivalries and messy compromises often conforms to.
E. Underlying the deliberative ideal is a powerful moral instuition about the nature of truly democratic association.
- AOption (a)
A, B and E only
- BOption (b)
A, B and C only
- COption (c)
B, C and D only
- DOption (d)
B, D and E only
View answer & explanationHide answer & explanation
Correct answer
A, B and E only
Why this answer is correct
The correct answer is A, B and E only
Explanation: Deliberative democracy, as a normative ideal, involves free and equal citizens engaging in public discourse, exchanging reasons with the aim of reaching a consensus on issues or policies, driven by a powerful moral intuition about the nature of truly democratic association.
Key Points
Deliberative democracy is a normative political theory that emphasizes the importance of public deliberation in the decision-making process of a democratic society. As a normative ideal, it sets out an aspirational vision of how democracy should ideally function, based on certain principles and values. Let's break down the key components of deliberative democracy:
Free and Equal Citizens:
- Free: Deliberative democracy posits that citizens should be free to express their opinions, participate in public discourse, and engage in the decision-making process without coercion or undue influence. Freedom in this context also implies access to information and resources necessary for informed decision-making.
- Equal: The ideal of equality means that each citizen's voice carries the same weight in the deliberative process. Regardless of social status, economic standing, or other demographic factors, everyone is considered equal in their right to participate and contribute to the public discourse.
Public Discourse: Deliberative democracy emphasizes the importance of open and inclusive public discourse. This involves citizens engaging in meaningful discussions, debates, and conversations about issues that affect the community. Public discourse is not limited to formal political institutions but includes a broader range of forums, both online and offline.
Exchange of Reasons: The heart of deliberative democracy lies in the exchange of reasons. Citizens are expected to provide justifications, arguments, and evidence to support their positions on various issues. This exchange is not just a matter of expressing preferences; it involves rational discourse aimed at convincing others through the force of reasoned argumentation.
Consensus Building: The ultimate goal of deliberative democracy is to reach a consensus or at least a reasonable agreement on issues. Consensus doesn't necessarily mean unanimous agreement, but rather a convergence of opinions through the process of rational discourse. This is seen as a way to ensure that decisions are not merely imposed by a majority but are the result of careful consideration and debate.
Moral Intuition about Democracy: Deliberative democracy is underpinned by a moral intuition or a set of ethical principles about the nature of democratic association. This often includes values such as equality, liberty, fairness, and the idea that decisions should be made collectively through rational deliberation rather than through arbitrary power.
Democratic Association: The term "democratic association" refers to the idea that citizens come together to collectively make decisions that affect their lives. It goes beyond the formal structures of government and includes a broader sense of community engagement and participation.
Additional Information
- Deliberative democracy envisions a political process where free and equal citizens engage in open, rational discourse, exchanging reasons with the goal of reaching a consensus on public issues.
- It reflects a moral intuition about the principles that should guide democratic association, emphasizing equality, liberty, and the collective pursuit of reasoned decisions.